"A well-written, tense, and intimate Holocaust memoir by an author with a remarkable war experience." from a review in Kirkus Reviews 9/1/1999
This
very interesting and moving memoir was written by the Holocaust survivor, Edith
Hahn Beer with the help of Susan Dworkin. The author, 85 at the time of its
publication in 1999, had grown up in Vienna, lived out most of the war years in
Germany under a false identity, and then left for England after the war where
she lived for over thirty years. After her second husband, Fred Beer died, she settled
in Netanya, Israel.
The
title of this memoir underlines the most unusual aspect of her life. Provided
with false identity papers by Austrians who did not support the Nazi regime, Edith
Hahn Beer married a German member of the Nazi party whom she met at an art
gallery, and who, after a short romance, declared his love. She shared her secret, but although his politics were not pro-Jewish,
his personality was such that he chafed at authority and felt compelled to
protect her and her secret. When he was drafted toward the end of the war, he became a Nazi officer.
Because
the author spent most of the war years in Germany, we get a detailed look at
what it was like to first be a slave laborer on an asparagus farm, then a
worker in a box factory. Then, once she
got her false identity papers, she became what she calls a “U-boat” – a person
living amongst the enemy - and we see what it was like living amongst Nazis and
Nazi sympathizers through her eyes. The details she provides allow us to become
emotionally involved in her close calls – in her need to be careful in order
not to give away her identity. This meant that she was constantly strategizing, constantly
being fearful that she might implicate herself and others who had helped her.
Edith Hahn Beer survived for a number of reasons: she was lucky, and she met a few sympathetic
Austrians and Germans who provided help and cover at crucial moments. Mostly it
was because she was smart and made the right decisions. However, she never
would have suffered as she did, she realized much later, had she decided to
leave Austria before Hitler invaded, as her sisters had done. For a variety of
reasons she had not wanted to leave her beloved Vienna and she, like many others, was
convinced that Hitler, who she considered an “idiot,” was not a real threat.
Throughout
the years she kept in touch with her Austrian Christian friend Christl Denner
Beran who helped save her life by agreeing to hand over her papers so that Edith Hahn
Beer could assume her identity. For this selfless act of humanity she has been
honored by Yad Vashem.
To see a trailer for the movie of the same name which includes a short clip of an interview with Edith Hahn Beer, click here.
To read an in-depth article on Germany's use of forced and slave labor during World War II called "German Industry and the Third Reich", click here.
People
Author’s
family (Father and mother were distant cousins. Both had Hahn surname.)
Author’s
father’s family
Leopold
Hahn – married Klothilde Hahn
Edith Hahn – daughter of Leopold and
Klothilde; married to Werner Vetter; married to Fred Beer; author
Maria Angela Vetter
Schluter – daughter of Edith and Werner
Mimi Hahn – daughter of Leopold and
Klothilde; married Milo Grenzbauer
Johanna (Hansi) Hahn – daughter of
Leopold and Klothilde
Gisela
Hahn Kirschenbaum – sister of Leopold
Isadore
Hahn – brother of Leopold
Selma Hahn – daughter of Isadore
Author’s
mother’s family
Ignatz
Hoffman – Klothilde Hahn’s uncle – exact relationship unclear
Klothilde Hahn –niece of Ignatz
Hoffman; married Leopold Hahn (see
above)
Richard Hahn – brother of Klothilde;
married Roszi
Elvira Hahn – sister of Klothilde
Jultschi
– daughter of Elvira; married Otto Ondrej
Otto Ondrej
– son of Jultschi and Otto
Marianne Hahn – sister of Klothilde;
married Adolf Robichek
Max
Sternbach – author’s cousin; relationship not clear
Friends
and Acquaintances
Bertschi
Beran – married to Christl Denner
Liesel
Brust
Kathe
Crohn
Heddy
Deutsch
Suri
Fellner
Philippe
Halsmann
Max
Hausner
Steffi
Kanagur
Sigfried
Kanagur – brother of Steffi
Mina
Katz
Lily
Kramer
Erna
Marcus
Felix
Roemer
Wolfgang Roemer – nephew of Felix
Ilse Roemer – sister of Wolfgang
Josef
(Pepi) Rosenfeld
Hermi
Schwarz
Places
Vienna,
Austria
Stockerau,
Austria
Hotel
Bristol, Badgastein, Austria
Hainburg,
Austria
Osterberg,
Germany
Munich,
Germany
Brandenburg,
Germany
Netanya,
Israel
Is there a way to contact Edith shah Berg? My aunt's name is Edith Hahn. She is my mother's sister. I know that my grandparents came from Austria and their name was Hahn. I am aware of my Great-Grandfather's name and his mother, a widow. I believe my great-grandparents were also cousins. As first names are often repeated in Jewish families, I have an eerie feeling that we may be realted and she might have the link tomEurope that I cannot seem to find.
ReplyDeleteJudy – Did you look at all of the family names that I’ve listed at the end of the review? Do any match? Her sister’s names are listed.
ReplyDeleteEdith Hahn Beer died in 2009 but her daughter, Angela Schluter, lives in London. You may be able to track her down via this blog. http://bfkbooks.com/interviews/angela-schluter-on-growing-up-in-england-with-edith-hahn-beer
If you find anything out, let me know.
Toby Bird